Join The Community

TPS QR Code

Search The Pelican Spectator

Sunday, May 15, 2011

Defense Secretary Focused on PDR and Counterinsurgency

Reference ID: 05MANILA1059 l Created: 2005-03-07 08:13 l Released: 2011-04-28 00:00
Classification: CONFIDENTIAL l Origin: Embassy Manila

This record is a partial extract of the original cable. 
The full text of the original cable is not available.
C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 02 MANILA 001059

SIPDIS

DEPT FOR EAP/PMBS
NSC FOR GREEN

E.O. 12958: DECL: 03/07/2015
TAGS: PREL MARR PINS PTER AS NZ JA RP
SUBJECT: DEFENSE SECRETARY FOCUSED ON PDR AND
COUNTERINSURGENCY

Classified By: (U) Political Officer Paul O'Friel
for reasons 1.4(b) and (d).

1.  (C) SUMMARY.  Defense Secretary Cruz has made Philippine
Defense Reform (PDR) the centerpiece of his tenure, and is
also focused on ending the country's multiple insurgencies
within the first six years of the 18-year PDR program.  His
new approaches include the "500 barangay" program, which will
enlist civilian agencies in the counterinsurgency effort.
According to Cruz's Chief of Staff, PDR will be high on the
Philippine Defense Secretary's agenda during his upcoming
trips to Australia and New Zealand.  END SUMMARY.

PDR FRONT AND CENTER
--------------------

2. (C) According to Brigadier General Lamberto "Bert" Sillona
(ret.), Secretary of National Defense Avelino Cruz's  Chief
of Staff, Cruz plans a series of meetings with Department of
National Defense (DND) personnel beginning March 7 to ensure
the entire Department understands and is on board with PDR
objectives.  Sillona told poloff that Cruz views PDR as the
centerpiece of his mandate as Defense Secretary, and its
success (or failure) will be the defining criterion of his
own tenure.

3.  (C) Admitting that many of the personnel and
organizational reforms proposed by PDR, such as a fixed
tenure for the Chief of Staff and service chiefs and reducing
the number of Philippine Army divisions, would require new
legislation, Sillona said his boss was pushing the DND staff
hard to come up with a new National Defense law.  A first
draft, however, failed to pass muster with the eagle-eyed
Cruz (one of the Philippines' most able attorneys and
previously legal counsel to the President).  Sillona claimed
Cruz "threw it in the trash" and directed his staff to come
up with a better effort.

4.  (C) Sillona commented that PDR will be high on the agenda
during Cruz's planned April 2005 visits to Canberra and
Wellington, where he intends to solicit Australian and New
Zealand support for PDR.  He separately also plans to enlist
Japanese backing for the effort.

ENDING INSURGENCIES
-------------------

5.  (C) Sillona stated Cruz wants within the first six years
of the 18-year PDR effort "to finish" the insurgencies
plaguing the Philippines.  According to Sillona, Cruz had
directed Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) Chief of Staff
General Efren Abu to come up with a concrete list of the
equipment he needs to combat the insurgencies.  Cruz told Abu
to work with an projected budget of 5 billion pesos
(approximately USD92.5 million) per year, but also instructed
the Chief of Staff to come up with possible funding sources,
e.g., new taxes or sale of excess military property.

6.  (C) Sillona also described Cruz's intention to develop a
more holistic approach to counterinsurgency.  He noted that
the "500 barangay (precinct)" program would identify
communities located primarily in areas controlled by the
Communist Party of the Philippines/New People's Army and
develop them as models of what the GRP can do for its
citizens.  AFP engineering, civil affairs, and medical
outreach efforts would be coordinated and in sync with
concurrent efforts by the Department of Public Works and
Highways (DPWH) and the Department of Social Welfare and
Development (DSWD).  Sillona related how Cruz had asked DPWH
to furnish a map of planned road construction over the next
five years.  Cruz then sought the advice of General on which
are the key roads and subsequently intervened personally with
President Arroyo to get DPWH to readjust its priorities to
meet counterinsurgency needs.  (Note:  The DND will brief
donors on the "500 barangay" program at the World
Bank-chaired donors' coordination group March 7-8. End Note.)

7.  (C) COMMENT.  Cruz reportedly told the Canadian
Ambassador during a recent courtesy call that he was
interested in only "boots and bullets," disappointing
Canadian attempts to flog high-ticket weapons.  Thus far in
his short tenure, Cruz seems to have focused on the right
priorities, and appears well served by his earlier role in
privatizing the moribund Philippine telecommunications
industry in the 1990's.  Taking a leaf out of a MBA textbook,
he has established an agenda and is now in the process of
reorienting the leviathan and often hide-bound Philippine
military to his way of thinking.  While canny and articulate
and with excellent access to his President, Cruz will also
need some luck and strong support from us to see PDR through.

Visit Embassy Manila's Classified website:
Ricciardone

Arroyo's Down Under Policy

Reference ID: 07MANILA1814 l Created: 2007-06-01 07:39 l  Released: 2011-04-28 00:00
Classification: CONFIDENTIAL l Origin: Embassy Manila

VZCZCXRO2240
OO RUEHCHI RUEHDT RUEHHM
DE RUEHML #1814/01 1520739
ZNY CCCCC ZZH
O 010739Z JUN 07
FM AMEMBASSY MANILA
TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC IMMEDIATE 6770
INFO RUEHZS/ASSOCIATION OF SOUTHEAST ASIAN NATIONS IMMEDIATE
RUEHBY/AMEMBASSY CANBERRA IMMEDIATE 9619
RUEHWL/AMEMBASSY WELLINGTON IMMEDIATE 3425
RUEKJCS/SECDEF WASHDC IMMEDIATE
RHHMUNA/CDRUSPACOM HONOLULU HI IMMEDIATE
C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 02 MANILA 001814

SIPDIS

SIPDIS

E.O. 12958: DECL: 06/01/2017
TAGS: PREL ECON MCAP PTER AS NZ RP
SUBJECT: ARROYO'S DOWN UNDER DIPLOMACY


Classified By: POL/C Scott Bellard, for reasons 1.4 (b) and (d)

1.  (SBU) Summary:  President Arroyo presided over the
signing of a number of bilateral security and economic
agreements during her recent visits to Australia and New
Zealand, most significantly a landmark Status of Forces
Agreement (SOFA) with Australia, which nonetheless will
likely face a difficult passage through the Philippine
Senate.  Australia also announced plans to donate
shallow-draft patrol boats to the Philippine military and to
provide human rights-related assistance.  The President's
trip to New Zealand included attendance at the Regional
Interfaith Dialogue, the signing of a law enforcement
cooperation agreement (with plans to coordinate with our
police advisor), assistance on human rights, and various
economic commitments from the New Zealand business community.
 Hecklers criticizing the Philippines on unlawful killings
hounded President Arroyo in both countries.  End Summary.

------------------------
Landmark Military Accord
------------------------

2.  (C) The cornerstone of President Arroyo's official visit
to Australia May 30-31 was the signing of the
Philippine-Australia Status of Forces Agreement (SOFA), which
would cover Australian military counterterrorism exercises
and training projects in the Philippines.  The SOFA awaits
ratification by the Australian Parliament and the Philippine
Senate.  Under negotiations for about two years, the SOFA
will enable Australia to engage in significantly more
military-to-military training and exercises and
counterterrorism assistance, along the lines of what the U.S.
is able to do under our Visiting Forces Agreement, although
Philippine officials were quick publicly to dismiss
comparisons between the two agreements.  Australian diplomats
in Manila confirmed that the SOFA will enable Philippine
authorities to gain custody over Australian soldiers accused
of crimes outside their official duties (as long as the
alleged offense would also be a crime in Australia) and that
detention and any eventual imprisonment would be on
Philippine soil, unlike the terms of the VFA.  There are
reciprocal provisions for Philippine troops who commit crimes
in Australia.

3.  (SBU) During the visit, Australia announced that it will
provide the Philippine military with about 30 shallow-draft
patrol boats (the exact quantity and model to be determined)
capable of operating in the marshlands of Mindanao.
According to Australian diplomats, tenders are already under
consideration, with an expectation that the first boats will
arrive by the end of 2007.  The two sides emphasized their
counterterrorism partnership, especially in Mindanao and
against transnational terrorism, but underscored that there
would be no Australia bases in the Philippines, nor would
Australian troops undertake combat operations.

4.  (SBU)  Australian officials in Canberra expressed concern
with unlawful killings in the Philippines, according to
contacts here, but also announced that the Australian
Government will provide AUS $250,000 for funding human rights
projects in the Philippines.  The two governments agreed to
work collaboratively to identify further assistance to
Philippine institutions dealing with human rights.

5.  (SBU)  Australian business representatives in Manila
noted some disappointment over a lack of commercial interest
during Arroyo's visit, including at an ANZ Bank-sponsored
Asia Society speech by Arroyo in Melbourne.

----------------------
New Zealand Highlights
----------------------

6.  (SBU) In New Zealand May 28-30, President Arroyo attended
the opening of the Asia-Pacific Regional Interfaith Dialogue,
the "prime reason" for the visit, according to New Zealand
diplomats in Manila.  The interfaith dialogue was a follow-on
to an inter-faith dialogue that Prime Minister Helen Clark
had attended in Cebu, which traced its origins to the
aftermath of the Bali bombing.

7.  (C) Arroyo also encountered some tough talk in Wellington
about the need to take action against unlawful killings, but
Prime Minister Clark agreed to provide as yet unspecified
assistance to the Philippine Commission on Human Rights.  A
team will visit Manila in the coming months to shape out a
program, which likely will consist of training rather than
hardware, according to the New Zealand Embassy.  New Zealand

MANILA 00001814  002 OF 002


also plans to enhance training for the Philippine National
Police (PNP) via a new law enforcement cooperation agreement.
 Diplomats here said that the plan is to coordinate with the
U.S. Senior Law Enforcement Advisor and our ongoing
assistance to the PNP Transformation Plan.  Top priorities
likely will include community policing and rights-based
training for the PNP.

8.  (SBU)  New Zealand diplomats expressed satisfaction with
new investment commitments related to mining and agriculture
(especially export of Philippine fruits), but did not yet
have many details.

-------------------
Not Without Protest
-------------------

9.  (SBU) Well-organized but small groups of hecklers
(including some from Manila) hounded President Arroyo at
several stops over alleged human rights violations in the
Philippines.  In Australia, a private airplane reportedly
towing a banner "Stop Gloria-fying Berdugo Palparon" (a
reference to a former Armed Forces of the Philippines
commander implicated in extra-judicial killings) flew
overhead during the welcome ceremony for President Arroyo.
There was also an unusual protest by the leftist Bayan Muna
"party-list" group outside the Australian Embassy in Manila
on May 31.

-------
Comment
-------

10.  (C) The SOFA with Australia is only the second such
agreement undertaken by the Philippines, after our VFA.
Ratification of the SOFA by the Philippine Senate promises to
be a contentious affair, as the new Senate will likely be
dominated by foes of the Arroyo Administration, with eyes on
the Presidential elections in 2010.  The absence on the scene
of former Defense Secretary Avelino Cruz, who had long
championed the Australian SOFA and similar agreements with
ASEAN members and who had laid the groundwork with the
departing 13th Congress, may weaken the Administration's
ability to persuade the new Senate to go along with this
SOFA, at least in the short run.

Visit Embassy Manila's Classified website:
http://www.state.sgov.gov/p/eap/manila/index.cfm
KENNEY